In 2004 major UK celebrities from the world of show business signed a letter calling for tolerance in regards to any imposition of a smoking ban in England. Well know names such as Joe Jackson, Bob Geldof, Simon Cowell and Chris Tarrant, along with leading artists and entrepreneurs signed a letter strongly opposing a ban on smoking in all public places.

The letter, which appears in The Times (25 September), argues that, "To smoke, to associate with smokers, or to operate a venue in which smoking is allowed should all be matters for individual choice. Smoking is legal, and in pubs and clubs it's fanatical smoke-haters who are the minority."

Signatories include Bob Geldof, pop mogul Simon Cowell, artist David Hockney, TV presenter Chris Tarrant, playwright Ronald Harwood, publisher Felix Dennis, singer Lisa Stansfield, writer Simon Gray, musician Joe Jackson and restaurateur Antony Worrall Thompson. Jackson,   said, "If you're going to make smoking illegal, make it illegal. Otherwise we have a right to smoke and have social places where we can smoke." Antony Worrall Thompson, patron of UK pro smoking action group FOREST, said, "Restaurants should have smoking and no-smoking areas and there should be certain levels of ventilation, extraction and air movement, but there is no justification for a total ban."


The Times letter in full:

Sir, We would like to raise our voices against calls to ban smoking in pubs, clubs and restaurants . Claims that the US hospitality industry is doing better since the New York ban was introduced are based on the recovery of the whole city economy since 9/11, and by including everything from McDonald's to liquor stores. But in bars and clubs the ban is widely hated.

According to a new independent survey of its first year, it has also cost 2,650 jobs, $50 million in earnings and $71.5 million to related businesses. Claims that the Irish ban is a success after six months are equally dubious, considering that anyone defying it faces fines of €3,000 or three months in prison.

Many people believe that the dangers of smoking and passive smoking are currently being exaggerated to the point of hysteria. The risks of passive smoke have never been proven beyond meaningless levels in a small minority of studies; wildly varying "estimates" of hundreds or thousands of deaths are based not on body counts but statistical projections.

To smoke, to associate with smokers, or to operate a venue in which smoking is allowed should all be matters for individual choice, not state coercion. Smoking is legal, and in pubs and clubs it's fanatical smoke-haters who are the minority. Nevertheless the hospitality industry is making great progress in voluntarily providing better air-cleaning systems and more choice.

We call on both government and the media to de-escalate the tension on this issue and let common sense and the free market decide the future of British social life.

Yours faithfully,

JOE JACKSON,
TREVOR BAYLIS,
SIMON COWELL,
FELIX DENNIS,
STEPHEN FRY,
BOB GELDOF,
SIMON GRAY,
MAGGI HAMBLING,
RONALD HARWOOD,
DAVID HOCKNEY,
BORIS JOHNSON,
LISA STANSFIELD,
CHRIS TARRANT,
ANTONY WORRALL THOMPSON